X

MLB Umpire Andy Fletcher Admits Missed Call on Yankees' Aaron Judge vs. Brewers

Jack MurrayApril 28, 2024

MILWAUKEE, WISCONSIN - APRIL 28: Aaron Judge #99 of the New York Yankees runs the bases following a home run against the Milwaukee Brewers during the first inning at American Family Field on April 28, 2024 in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. (Photo by Stacy Revere/Getty Images)
Stacy Revere/Getty Images

It looks like Aaron Judge got away with an interference call during the New York Yankees game against the Milwaukee Brewers Sunday.

Judge was sliding into second when his hand made contact with a throw towards first from Willy Adames. The play was ruled incidental and did not result in a double play.

YES Network @YESNetwork

More thoughts on Aaron Judge's slide from Brewers manager Pat Murphy and Crew Chief Andy Fletcher. <a href="https://t.co/KSCeKfOz06">pic.twitter.com/KSCeKfOz06</a>

Following the game, crew chief Andy Fletcher told reporters that they made an incorrect call on the play.

Curt Hogg @CyrtHogg

Crew chief Andy Fletcher said they missed the call on Judge's slide. <br><br>"On the field we got together and did the best we could to come up with a correct answer. After looking at it on replay, it appears that the call was missed. It was an unnatural part of his slide."

"On the field we got together and did the best we could to come up with a correct answer," Fletcher said, per Hogg. "After looking at it on replay, it appears that the call was missed. It was an unnatural part of his slide."


Following the game, Brewers manager Pat Murphy criticized the call and said that while he doubts Judge intended to make contact with the throw, he believes that Judge did intend to "purposely obstruct" with the play.

The play occurred during the sixth inning, with Judge being the only runner on base and no outs having been recorded prior to the fielders choice. The score was tied 4-4, and New York would put up seven runs in the inning to build an 11-4 lead. The Yankees would go on to win the game 15-5.

While the rally could have happened with the correct call, starting the inning with a double play surely would have been a momentum boost for the Brewers. Instead, New York grabbed a lead it would not relinquish before Milwaukee returned to the dugout.

The Yankees improved to 19-10 with the victory while Milwaukee dropped to 17-10.